Monday, June 21, 2010

It is not necessary to sin


Practically perfect in every way
Image used with permission, CC frangipani photograph


I have another guestpost out today. It's here on Jason Stasyszen's blog.

It follows some others that I've written.

Today's is about sin. If you're not of a theist or spiritual sort of ilk, feel free to call that "making mistakes." The idea still applies.

The question on the table is simple: is it inherently necessary that we sin? The short answer is no. There may have been some point at which the identity of every human was "sinner" by requirement, but this time, if it ever existed, has passed. We are empowered not to sin. The identity may still be there. The requirement is not.

Here's the gist:

  • We make mistakes because we make the wrong decisions before we act.


  • We wouldn't have made the mistakes if we'd made the right decision.


  • We're allowed to make right decisions.


  • We have an example of a human being who always made the right decisions (as well as many others who learned to, to varying degrees). We can follow these examples and take them as role models.


  • We don't have to make wrong decisions.


In short, it's our responsibility to make right decisions, and to accept the consequence for wrong ones. It's a convenient (and wrong) cop-out to blame our failures on the weaknesses of humanity. It's an individual issue, not a corporate issue.

The good news: Humans can improve. Whether this is with outside intervention or of our own initiative is an issue for moral and social philosophies to debate.

Happy World Humanist Day.

Read Becoming Who You Are
on Jason Stasyszen's blog.

Comments (5)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Jeff, I would go a step further--in order to make right decisions, we need to have clarity in our thinking. Or, in other words, are our thinking and decisions rational and reasonable? So many of us make decisions based on emotions or circumstances (which can change from one moment to the next). This is one reason why we should "work" to come beyond religion into a personal relationship with God who is our Father. In Isaiah 1:18, He says, "Come now, and let us reason together..." By coming to God and reasoning with Him, we can find stability in a world of turmoil, and we can learn how to consistently make the right decisions.
3 replies · active 776 weeks ago
Actually, I'm kinda scared of the danger of that outlook. A rational religion is a ritualistic litany devoid of spirituality. A relationship requires an emotional component: commitment, attraction, desire to interact with the other, happiness at their successes, joy at their failures. It maintains a dynamic that makes us something other than machines.

This is part of who we are, and who we were made to be. This is not to say that we should trust all of our distorted emotions (we should not), but it is to say that we do damage to ourselves to deny them completely.

Haven't we been directed also to work out our salvation with fear and trembling?

Wacky stuff...
I don't see how rational equates with ritualistic litany--from my stand point, rational means I've taken the time to think through what I believe and test its reasonableness. Take, for example, the matter of evil. Last weekend, I heard a pastor state that God causes suffering. I think he was looking at all the horrible circumstances in the world in the context of God being sovereign. I don't know if he's ever read James 1:13-17 or not; James cautions us to not err because every good and perfect gift comes from God and he is not variable. In other words, He doesn't give a good gift and then turn around and give an evil gift. God is good and His love is absolute. If we begin to think through what we believe in that context, we may well find our beliefs being challenged and we might learn some new concepts. So, rather than rationality being ritualistic and being a litany (I don't participate in litanies), it is an exercise of thinking. And, in today's world, we really need to think clearly. 1 of 2
By the way, concerning God's sovereignty, He is sovereign in that no one rules over him at all. However, He limited His sovereignty in His creations--the angelic realm and our world--when He created choice. Deuteronomy 30:15-20 states that God has given us a clearly defined choice. Once we understand that choice, once we understand what Christ accomplished on the cross, and once we understand the power of God's absolute love, we will take our places as the sons of God and deal with the evil in our world.

Finally, I have my share of emotions (sometimes more than my share), but I try to make choices based on clear thinking. 2 of 2
These are some deep thoughts... I just wanted to pop by and say I appreciated your guest post at Jason's yesterday. Thanks!

Post a new comment

Comments by